Are you partial to the occasional cigar after dinner?
If so, do you collect cigars and keep them in stock so you always have something exciting when guests are over?
You’ll need the best cigar humidor if you want to keep those stogies fresh, aromatic, and packed with flavor.
Luckily, we’ve exhaustively researched the finest models on the market and today we bring you no less than 15 humidors all designed with one thing only in mind: to keep your precious cigars fresher for longer.
A cigar humidor is a simple device designed to optimize storing cigars for the long haul. These devices allow you to keep your cigars at precisely the right level of humidity, between 64F and 75F.
If you want to store your cigars long-term without impacting their flavor and aroma, a great humidor is a must. If you keep your cigars properly stored like this, they will actually improve with age rather than getting worse. What better return on investment could you ask for?
Now, while this might not be the most complicated buying decision you’ll encounter, it pays to arm yourself with a few basics about cigar storage. There’s not much to learn so, by the end of today, you’ll be an expert when it comes to preserving the flavor of your investment.
First, we’ll give you a snapshot review of all the best humidors. We’ve chosen models of varying capacities from small travel humidors that house just 15 cigars to larger freestanding units with space for hundreds of Cohibas.
When we’re done with our reviews, we’ll give you a concise buying guide to help you all the way when you’re shopping cigar humidors.
Let’s get right down to business now with those reviews.
I. The 15 Best Cigar Humidors
1. Our #1 Pick: Case Elegance Cedar Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
Our favorite humidor overall is this understated desktop unit from Case Elegance. How does it shape up, then?
Fashioned from Spanish cedar, you get a storage environment ideal for keeping your prized cigars fresher for longer.
The integrated humidification system keeps the humidity levels between 65% and 70% so you won’t need to tinker around with any settings. You’ll need to factor in the solution for this humidifier. The manufacturer recommends CE Humidor Solution.
You also get gel and hydro sticks included to enhance the environment further.
The magnetically-sealed enclosure keeps your cigars in a perfectly contained environment so you enjoy them at their very best even if you keep them for years.
Anyone with a love for cigars probably has a comparable hatred for the volume of accessories you need. Keep your lighter, cigar cutter, and any other paraphernalia in the storage drawer onboard.
The wooden humidor is crowned with a tempered glass lid. You can view your collection without breaching the storage environment as an added kicker to an already great package. You can’t go wrong with this humidor from Case Elegance.
2. Best Budget: Bald Eagle Handmade Cigar Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
Not everyone wants a hulking cigar humidor with space for a hundred stogies. If you prefer a more compact approach to cigar storage, Bald Eagle delivers in fine style.
Capacity is designed to accommodate 20 to 25 cigars, depending on the size.
The Spanish cedar finish gives you just the right environment for cigar storage. There’s a movable partition inside so you can divide your collection with ease.
If you’re concerned about scratching up your desktop, you needn’t be. Velvet pads underneath ensure you don’t leave any scrapes behind.
There’s a hygrometer onboard so you can monitor humidity levels and make certain your cigars are being preserved at their very best.
The only real blowback about this product concerns not the humidor itself, but the lackluster customer care that’s caused many customers to complain about this online.
Given the overall build and finish of this humidor, though, we wouldn’t expect you to need to call customer service in the first place.
3. Best Cigar Humidor and Cooler: Whynter Cigar Humidor and Cooler (Holds up to: 400+ Cigars)
If you need more room than a desktop humidor provides, this freestanding cooler and humidor from Whynter is the perfect solution.
Firstly, you’ll need to make sure you have the space to accommodate this unit. It measures up at 20 x 17 x 29 inches so it’s pretty bulky. In return for this oversized footprint, you get a correspondingly large 2.5 cubic feet capacity. This translates to storage for 400 cigars.
The temperature of this cooler can be adjusted from 54F to 65F giving you just the right environment for your cigar collection.
Thanks to thermoelectric cooling, you won’t get any annoying noise, and there’s no vibration to shake up your cigars either.
The removable drawers and shelves are made from Spanish cedar, the preferred material for humidors the world over.
Whether you want this humidor for your study at home, or for use in a commercial setting, build quality is impressive and you should get years of faithful service.
4. Best For Travel: Cigar Caddy Humidor (Holds: 10 Cigars)
Are you a frequent traveler unable to go without your cigars on the road? Well, there’s no need to sacrifice those stogies if you invest in the Cigar Caddy.
This neat and compact travel humidor measures up at just 8 x 4 x 2.5 inches, and it’s lightweight enough to slip in your hand luggage without burdening yourself. Despite this small footprint, you get enough space inside for 15 of your choicest cigars so you can celebrate that next business deal on the road in style.
Waterproof to 100 feet and designed to float on water, the crush-proof container can also withstand extremes of temperature from -10F through 175F. All of this is to say the rugged humidor is perfect for use on a boat or any other hostile environment where you want the sanctity of your cigars preserved at all costs.
In spite of such robust overall performance and such convenience, overall build quality and finish are both slightly disappointing. We hope future iterations of this otherwise fine humidor address these shortcomings.
5. Mantello Cigar Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
Mantello has a deep bench of humidors and this desktop model gives you ample space for up to 50 cigars at a highly affordable price. Not only that, this humidor is currently up for grabs at a steep discount so act quickly to snare a real bargain.
Finished in handcrafted rosewood, the inside of the box is made from Spanish cedar giving you good eat looks along with the ideal conditions for long-term cigar storage.
The efficient humidifier baked in is designed to keep your cigars at just the right level of humidity. You can keep an eye on these humidity levels thanks to the onboard hygrometer.
The success or failure of any humidor rests on the quality of the seal. The Mantello gets this nailed with a tight seal to keep the environment regulated.
The cedar wood divider allows you to separate your cigars neatly.
With a scratch-resistant bottom so you won’t end up ruining your beloved desk, this humidor gives you the full package at a price you’ll love. Act quickly and you could benefit from that aggressive discount, too.
6. Capri Desktop Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
Next up we have another solid desktop model from Capri. We like this darker model with its subtle mahogany finish. If this color is not to your liking, choose from a handful of other options including red, white, black, and blue.
This box will hold up to 50 cigars so it’s ideal if you have a budding collection but you’re not yet ready for a freestanding humidor.
Lined with Spanish cedar, you’ll benefit from the trademark aroma and the first-class moisture retention the material is famous for.
If you’re giving this humidor as a gift to a loved one, why not have their name engraved on the optional plate? That will make a wonderful present even better and more personalized.
Whether you’re gifting this cigar humidor or keeping it for yourself, the contents of the box can be easily viewed through the transparent window so you can tempt your guests with the after-dinner treats on offer without breaching the storage environment.
The hygrometer is mounted on the front of the humidor allowing you to see at a glance that humidity levels are in check and your cigar collection is being cosseted.
7. XIFEI Cigar Humidor (Holds: 18 Cigars)
If you’re looking for a humidor with a twist, this acrylic jar from XIFEI is worth a look.
While the transparent acrylic is not the usual material used for humidors – Spanish cedar takes that crown – it’s surprisingly effective, and also remarkably pockert-friendly.
The sealed rubber gasket keeps cigars or anything else you store inside airtight.
The dimensions of this jar are just 7 x 5 inches yet you’ll fit 15 to 20 cigars inside. While this is insufficient for a growing collection, beginners and anyone only wanting to store a handful of cigars might find this novel humidor plugs the gap they’re looking to fill.
If you’re still caught on the fence and not sure if this unconventional humidor will deliver, here’s the best part. The manufacturer is so confident in the quality of this product that they offer an unconditional refund at any stage during the first 2 months after purchase. What have you got to lose?
8. Old World Desktop Humidor (Holds up to: 100 Cigars)
If you have a larger cigar collection and you’re looking to house 100 stogies, this old world walnut humidor from The Quality Imports Store will make a commanding presence on any desk.
The outside of this distressed walnut unit is emblazoned with an antique map of the world. Trace the lineage of your favorite cigars as you relax in your chair and fire up a Cohiba.
The kiln-dried cedar inside allows you to keep all the moisture while also enjoying that unmistakable fresh scent.
SureSeal Technology gives you the confidence of knowing you won’t be let down by a classic weak point on humidors.
Underneath the cover of this humidor, you’ll find a glass hygrometer with a brass ring. This lets you keep a close eye on humidity levels so you can be sure your cigars are not being neglected.
If you’re not sure about the sizing and coloring of this humidor, the manufacturer has a deep bench of alternatives well worth exploring.
As an added bonus, this humidor is lockable so you can keep your inquisitive teens away from your prized cigars and enjoy them year-round at their best.
9. Mantello Cigar Humidor (Holds: 50-100 Cigars)
Next up we have another fine humidor from Mantello, this time capable of housing up to 100 cigars, depending on the size. As with all humidors, if you favor huge stogies, you’ll find capacity is closer to 50.
As you know, cigars need to be stored at just the right humidity levels if you want to preserve the taste and aroma. This humidor will do all that for you with the humidifier baked in. There’s also the standard hygrometer so you can keep an eye on those levels and take action if they fall out of kilter.
The cedar-lined tray is designed to promote moisture retention and the divider lets you keep your collection organized and compartmentalized.
The felt-lined bottom and brass hinges set off the mahogany build nicely. The hygrometer’s surround is slightly garish but certainly not a deal-breaker. What is more distressing is the quality of the hygrometer itself. Many users feel it’s inaccurate.
Despite such generous capacity, the squat box measures just 13.5 x 9.4 x 6.3 inches so it won’t dominate your desk.
10. Megacra Desktop Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
This understated and elegant humidor from Megacra comes in a dark or pale brown to suit your office or study décor.
The spacious box measures up at 9.25 x 7.9 x 3.1 inches and allows you to accommodate between 25 and 50 cigars according to the ring gauge.
The seal is super-tight so you eliminate any weakness. We did encounter some users complaining about issues with the seal, though, so you should do your own due diligence here.
If you need to doctor the humidity levels, the integrated hygrometer makes this straightforward. Everything about using this humidor is a breeze even if you’re a complete beginner to cigar storage. The comprehensive care manual included comes with some useful tips if you’re just getting started and need a helping hand.
Thanks to the adjustable divider, you’ll be able to subdivide your cigars by type or quality.
11. Octodor Cigar Humidor (Holds: 50-100 Cigars)
Do you have a larger cigar collection that needs attention but you don’t fancy the idea of a huge freestanding humidor? Well, the Octodor gives you an aesthetically elegant alternative with a truly impressive capacity. How does it shape up, then?
Well, the first thing you’ll benefit from is a 100-cigar capacity, although with much larger cigars this will be slightly reduced.
As with all Casa Elegance humidors, you get a digital hygrometer allowing you to stay on top of humidity levels.
The felt-lined drawer provides a plush home for those Montecristos, and the Hydro System patented by the manufacturer keeps humidity levels in that perfect sweet spot required to maintain the taste and aroma of those precious cigars.
Accessory storage is roomy so you can keep all that cigar paraphernalia to hand without needing an extra box to worry about.
Despite these impressive storage properties and substantial capacity, this humidor measures 13.75 x 9.5x 8.6 inches and weighs in at 13 pounds so it won’t overtake your office desk.
12. Prestige Import Cigar Humidor (Holds up to: 125 Cigars)
As we edge to the end of our quest for the best cigar humidors, you’ve hopefully now seen a number of likely candidates that fit your tastes and budget.
If you’re looking for a freestanding unit but you don’t need capacity for hundreds and hundreds of cigars, the Prestige Import Group has a neat solution in the form of this Milano Countertop Display Humidor.
You’ll have space for up to 125 cigars so most cigar lovers should have enough room for a modest collection.
The angled shelves all come with dividers so you can display and show off your budding collection without the storage environment being interfered with. With all sides made from glass, you enjoy viewing through 360 degrees and you’ll never need to open the humidor. Until, of course, you want a cigar. And when you do pull out that stogie, the taste and aroma will be perfectly preserved.
Although we’d like to see a slightly finer attention to detail and finish to this humidor, the overall effect is sufficiently impressive to get our recommendation.
13. Woodronic Handmade Cigar Humidor (Holds: 10-20 Cigars)
This handmade cigar humidor from Woodronic is a sleek and understated modern classic that manages to look great in both minimalist and traditional offices.
Finished in ebony, you can choose from another couple of colorways in paler woods.
The acrylic window lets you spy on your cigars without disturbing the environment they’re stored in. The tight seal adds another layer of security and allows you to store up to 50 cigars for the long haul without losing either the taste or aroma.
The digital hygrometer gives you a constant read on humidity levels. Make sure your investment is protected and take prompt action if you see the humidity dipping or rising.
You get an ashtray included with this box, and there’s also a double guillotine cutter made from stainless steel to complete an impressive package with everything you need to kick back and enjoy a great cigar at its best with no degradation over time. What are you waiting for?
14. Audew Cigar Cooler and Humidor (Holds: 300 Cigars)
The Audew cigar cooler and humidor gives you a large and commanding storage unit for up to 300 cigars. This makes a great addition to any library, study, or man cave. The humidor is also ideal for a small store.
Aside from that bumper capacity, what else do you get for your money?
The 3 shelves are fully adjustable so you can accommodate and neatly categorize a growing cigar collection.
Consistent levels of humidity are maintained through air closed loop circulation. The drawers and the shelving are designed to sit flush to the cabinet’s front edge and the integrated fan. This promotes outstanding airflow and keeps humidity levels perfectly in check so you get the storage environment you need.
You also benefit from a moisture container so you can fine-tune humidity to create the optimum storage spot for your cigars.
The Spanish cedar finish might not be novel, but it’s a favorite for humidors with just cause.
For a large-capacity cigar humidor that won’t require too much room to accommodate, we can’t recommend the Audew cooler and humidor strongly enough.
15. Kendal Desktop Cigar Humidor (Holds: 25-50 Cigars)
Lats but by no means least in our best cigar humidor reviews comes this desktop model that looks much like several others on our list.
This is the thing with great humidors, though: you don’t need them to reinvent the wheel, you need them to perform a simple task of humidity regulation efficiently, and the Kendal does that in fine style.
You’ll get the premium cedar build you need for optimum storage conditions. Moisture retention is uppermost while the sealing is tight and ensures the cigars stay at just the right level of humidity to keep them at their most aromatic and flavorsome.
With enough capacity for 60 cigars, you should have more than enough room for a small, young collection of cigars. You can always upgrade to a more substantial freestanding model if you start accumulating more and more cigars over time.
As with all the best humidors, your desk will be protected from scratches thanks to the velvet bottom in place.
For an affordable and sleek desktop humidor from a highly reputable brand, we’d strongly recommend this model.
II. Things You Should Consider
Focus on the following areas and you should have no trouble finding the best humidor the easy way.
- Capacity vs Dimensions
- Drawer Materials
- Seal and Lid
The first major decision you’ll face when choosing a cigar humidor is what type makes the best fit for you and the size of your cigar collection.
Here are your main options:
The beauty of a case humidor, commonly also referred to as a desktop humidor, is the fact it’s a portable option you can easily take with you if you’re heading to a friend’s house for dinner. There are even smaller and more travel-friendly options if you need something you can slip in your hand luggage more easily.
Desktop humidors make a neat compromise, though, while still giving you adequate capacity to house a growing collection of cigars.
This type of humidor typically has stainless steel or brass hinges rather than a vacuum seal. This is arguably their biggest weak point.
A freestanding cooler gives you even more latitude to accommodate a larger cigar collection.
You’ll be free to adjust both the temperature and the humidity on these models so you can stay in full control of all aspects of cigar storage even if you’re a complete beginner.
This type of unit is often combined with a wine cooler.
These storage jars have tight capacities so you’ll struggle to store much more than 10 cigars.
As the ultimate travel-friendly humidor, though, they take some beating.
With that decision taken care of – and all that counts here is buying in line with your needs – it’s time to understand that size matters when it comes to cigar humidors.
Capacity vs Dimensions
You should think about the size of the humidor in all senses.
Firstly and most importantly, assess the capacity of the units on your shortlist set against the size of your collection now. You should of course make allowances for the cigars you intend to buy in the future, too.
You can’t consider capacity in isolation, though. Larger capacity humidors typically eat up far more space into the bargain so make certain that you have room to accommodate any humidors on your shortlist.
If you need a good degree of capacity but you also have limited space in your office or study, many of the models we review today are quite squat and compact giving you the best of both worlds.
Next up, consider the overall build of the humidor.
Cedar wood is most commonly used for its exceptional moisture retention qualities. This is the most popular material used for the outer chassis of desktop humidors.
Larger freestanding models are normally made from rugged stainless steel so you’ll get impressive lifespan.
More importantly, though, is what the drawers are made from…
You should look for cedar drawers so your cigars will be stored with the right degree of moisture retained rather than sucked away by inappropriate materials.
If you’ve never seen a hygrometer before, they’re the equivalent of a thermometer but used to measures humidity levels rather than temperature.
Since the most crucial part of cigar storage centers on keeping humidity levels between 64F and 75F, you’ll need a hygrometer so you can be confident that everything is as it should be.
Check for user reviews and any complaints of inaccuracy here.
Seal and Lid
You should check that the cigar humidors you’re looking at come with sufficiently airtight seals and no negative blowback from consumers.
A humidor with a poorly-sealed lid defeats the very purpose of buying one in the first place. You need your storage environment to remain consistent and perfectly sealed.
From LCDs to locks, cigar cutters to ashtrays, some humidors come with some extras bundled. Rather than looking for the one with most bells and whistles, pay attention only those add-ons you’ll meaningfully use.
Just like with size, you shouldn’t consider price in isolation, and you shouldn’t focus purely on the bottom line.
You should think of your cigar collection in the same way you do your wine collection: as an investment. So, when you’re shopping for humidors, you’re looking to make a further investment purely to protect your primary investment. By selling yourself short and buying a cheap, subpar humidor, you’ll only cost yourself money and enjoyment over time.
Instead, buy the best cigar humidor you can afford and don’t begrudge spending a little to bring out the best qualities in the cigars you’re saving for a special occasion.
Now, before we round out for the day, we’ve curated a list of the most frequently asked questions about cigar humidors.
1) How long should I keep my cigars in the humidor for?
There’s no hard and fast rule here. As a general benchmark, though, you should leave any new cigars in your humidor for 3 months or so. Just like wine, cigars improve with age as long as you pay proper attention to their storage environment. From this point, the cigars will have absorbed all the flavor they are likely to. As long as you keep them within the recommended band of humidity, you can keep cigars for years.
2) Do I leave the wrappers on my cigars when I place them in a humidor?
Again, there’s no right or wrong answer here. Since wrapper are actually designed to keep cigars fresh, it makes little sense to remove them. Also, if you have a growing collection, it can be awkward to identify unmarked cigars. Our advice is to leave the wrappers on.
3) Is a cigar cutter essential?
Yes, it is. Any cigars with torpedo or rounded ends need cutting so you can smoke them properly. Some humidors come with cutters included. If not, you don’t need to spend a fortune to get a serviceable cutter.
4) Why can’t I just keep my cigars in the refrigerator?
The fridge might seem like an ideal spot to stash your cigars, but nothing could be further from the truth. It’s cool enough for sure, but possibly too cold. Also, the humidity levels inside a refrigerator are far too low.
5) What happens if my cigars are stored at high levels of humidity?
This can be just as damaging as storing cigars in an environment where the humidity levels are too low. If they’ve been stored in humid environments, the cigars will burn and also draw poorly. At 72%, cigars start to absorb moisture. This adversely affects both flavor and aroma.
6) How can I determine if a cigar is bad?
If you feel a cigar and it’s crunchy or hard, it’s dried out and will be past its best. A cigar that feels spongy is too wet.
7) Is it possible to save a dried cigar?
Yes, as long as the wrapper is still in place. You’ll also need to hope that not all of the oils have evaporated from the tobacco, or the cigar will be beyond repair and fit for the trash can. The bad news is that it could take weeks to rehydrate a cigar, so don’t make plans to smoke it any time soon.
8) Is it really true that cigars get better with age?
Yes, it is. A full-bodied cigar will certainly taste better as it ages, as long as you store it correctly.
9) What extra benefits do I get from a cigar cooler?
With a cooler, you can regulate temperature as well as humidity.
10) Is a cigar humidor necessary?
If you want to keep cigars in the short-term, there’s no real need to get a humidor unless you really want one. Anyone intending to store cigars for the long haul, though, needs one of these boxes or coolers.
The best cigar humidor is not difficult to find. If you stick with any of the models we review today, you can buy with your eyes wide open and a clear idea of where they fall down, not just where they excel.
The most important elements to consider when you’re humidor shopping are the aesthetics and the dimensions. After all, you’re likely to have the humidor on plain view on your desk. Why settle for something you’re not too keen on when there are so many elegant, design-driven humidors out there?
The good news is, if you encounter a humidor not on out shortlist, you can make use of the tips in our humidor buying guide to ensure you get the most appropriate model for your needs.
Before you head off today, bookmark BriccoWine and pop back soon. We’re building up for a busy holiday season and we’ll have plenty to share we you, our readers. See you soon!